Mortgage Prepayment vs. Investing Calculator
Compare allocating surplus cash toward mortgage principal versus investing in index funds. Accounts for compound interest divergence, tax drags, and the post-debt investment pivot.
Parameters
Long-Term Wealth Projection
The Math of Prepaying Debt vs. Investing in Index Funds
Evaluating the mathematical trade-off between guaranteed risk-free returns and long-term market equity premiums.
1. Guaranteed Risk-Free Yield vs. Equity Risk Premium
Prepaying a mortgage delivers a guaranteed, after-tax rate of return precisely equal to your mortgage interest rate. For example, prepaying a 5.5% loan produces an effective risk-free return of 5.5% with zero market volatility.
In contrast, allocating capital into broad-market index funds (such as the S&P 500 or total global indices) historically yields nominal annualized returns of approximately 9.5%–10% over multi-decade periods, but introduces price volatility and sequence-of-returns risk.
2. Tax Drag & The Post-Payoff Pivot
To compare the two paths fairly, taxable account investments must account for tax drag on dividends and capital gains:
The Strategic Pivot: When a homeowner eliminates their mortgage debt early, they unlock their entire scheduled monthly payment (principal + interest). Reinvesting that total freed-up cash flow into index portfolios can rapidly narrow the wealth gap against pure investing strategies.
Common Mortgage vs. Investing Scenarios
Explore side-by-side math simulations comparing guaranteed mortgage interest savings against equity index returns.
5% Mortgage vs. S&P 500 Index Funds (8%)
When your mortgage borrowing rate sits around 5% and long-term equities average an expected 8% to 10% nominal return, you face a classic 300 basis point spread between a guaranteed risk-free return and market equity risk premium.
Extra $500/Month: Mortgage Prepayment vs. Investing
Allocating a consistent monthly surplus of $500 toward your mortgage cuts years off your amortization, but directing that same $500 into dollar-cost-averaged index funds leverages decades of compounding growth.
$50,000 Lump Sum: Pay Down Mortgage vs. Invest
Receiving a $50,000 windfall raises an immediate capital allocation decision: lock in guaranteed interest savings by paying down your mortgage principal, or deploy it into compounding index funds.
6% Mortgage vs. Tax-Free Investing (TFSA/Roth)
When mortgage rates reach 6% or higher, the hurdle rate for investing increases. Even with equities returning 7% to 8%, the risk premium narrows significantly when compared against a guaranteed 6% debt savings.
3% Low-Rate Mortgage vs. Market Investing
Borrowers with locked-in low fixed rates around 3% possess cheap capital. In this bracket, virtually all historical market cycles strongly favor investing surplus cash rather than rushing to pay off low-cost debt.