The Classic Benchmark Spread
Paying Off a 5% Mortgage vs. Investing in the S&P 500
When your mortgage borrowing rate sits around 5% and long-term equities average an expected 8% to 10% nominal return, you face a classic 300 basis point spread between a guaranteed risk-free return and market equity risk premium.
Strategic Outcome Summary
Comparison Horizon: 25 YearsInterest Saved (Prepayment)$97,537Mortgage paid off 7.3 years early
Investment Portfolio Value$478,683At 8% annualized return
Projected Net Spread+$381,146Investing ahead of debt
Interest Saved via Debt Payoff: $97,537 (17%)Market Investment Wealth: $478,683 (83%)
Guaranteed Risk-Free Savings (5% rate)Compounded Market Growth (8% return)
Financial ParametersAdjust figures
A guaranteed 5% risk-free return matches roughly a 6.25% taxable investment return. However, over a 25-year horizon, an 8% compounding equity portfolio generally builds a larger net worth cushion.
Strategy Comparison Breakdown
Strategy A: Prepay Mortgage
Guaranteed return of 5%. Completely eliminates future mortgage interest payments.
Interest Saved:$97,537
New Payoff Time:17.8 yrs
Strategy B: Invest in Market
Compounding returns at 8%. Maintains full portfolio liquidity.
Portfolio Value:$478,683
Total Invested:$150,000
Related Optimization Tools
Mathematical Analysis
The 300 Basis Point Spread & Tax Arbitrage
Every dollar applied to a 5% mortgage delivers an immediate, guaranteed 5.0% return through interest avoidance. Conversely, broad market equities offer historical gross compounding of 8–10%, but come with volatility and potential capital gains taxation.
Key Strategic Takeaways
- Mortgage prepayment provides a guaranteed, after-tax return immune to market corrections.
- Equities held in tax-sheltered accounts (like TFSAs or Roth IRAs) benefit from unhindered compound growth without tax drag.
- Once the mortgage is fully retired, redirecting the former monthly mortgage payment into equities accelerates wealth catch-up.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is it better to pay off a 5% mortgage or invest in index funds?
- Mathematically, investing typically yields a higher terminal net worth if equities return 8% or more, especially in tax-sheltered accounts. However, paying down a 5% mortgage eliminates guaranteed debt expense and provides peace of mind.
- How does tax drag affect the mortgage vs. invest equation?
- In non-registered (taxable) accounts, capital gains and dividend taxes reduce an 8% nominal return to roughly 6.5–7.0% net, narrowing the spread against a guaranteed 5% debt payoff.